Posted by: vgag | March 6, 2010

The Black & White Sequel: Bad News

In my Black & White fan fiction, I’ve left poor Ying Xiong down a ravine in a national forest, suffering from imminent hypothermia, whilst his partner scours the trail above, searching for him in vain. I’ve been really gratified that so many fans are reading my series, and I apologise for leaving you cliff-hung for so long. Last weekend, I had planned to write Episode 4, in which Ying Xiong is rescued only to land in a very slashy situation, possibly involving a jacuzzi.

However, first I had to come to terms with some very bad show biz news. According to a recent UDN report, the much anticipated feature film that was supposed to serve as a sequel to the high rating television series is no longer going to be filmed as such: Vic ‘Zai Zai’ Zhou has dropped out, signing on with other projects and will not after all reprise his role as the flamboyant but troubled Chen Zai Tian. Mark Zhao (Chao) will still be in it, though, with a new male and a new female lead from the mainland. Alas!

Vic 'Zai Zai" Zhou (left) and Mark Zhao in the title sequence from Black & White

There had been rumours about the project faltering for awhile. The tabloids always put a deeply personal and melodramatic spin on situations that in reality more often than not centre on investors, contracts and scheduling. Thus, the on dit was that Zai Zai had his nose well and truly put out of joint when the egregiously talented and undeniably handsome newcomer, Mark Zhao, won the the 2009 Golden Bell for best actor in a television series. Zai Zai had also been nominated for the award, and he is said to have felt very keenly the consequent loss of face at losing to Mark, given that the role Zai Tian (Pizi)  was not only the top billing but had also been expressly written for him. The tension between the two stars was further increased by allegations that perhaps Mark’s father, Zhao Shu-Hai, who has a lot of clout in the industry, had waved some red envelopes in the vicinity of the judges to sway their decision in Mark’s favour.

I have no idea how much substance there is in this version of affairs (though I strongly doubt the bribery charge), but clearly there was a misunderstanding between the two stars at the Golden Bell awards ceremony. When Mark gave his acceptance speech, he cried. I haven’t seen any images of this, but I’d imagine it was his trademark technique, where a single fat tear spills down his cheek, out of only one of his startling, ‘Korean’, single-lidded eyes.* Anyway, having sobbed, Mark then invited Zai Zai up on the stage, as if to share the award, but he refused, whether out of his usual diffidence or out of anger and humiliation at losing is unclear.

Wu Ying Xiong (Mark Zhao) in a lachrymose scene from Black & White

Neveridol may as well belatedly weigh into the debate over who should have won the much-disputed Golden Bell. On the first viewing of the series, I gave the honours to Mark over Zai Zai. Mark played his role with an open-hearted sincerity and a fierce intensity, and I came to believe in Ying Xiong’s angst-ridden perfectionism and occasional impulsive sorties into action. On the other hand, I thought Zai Zai’s performance was overly melodramatic and extremely hammy, and not up to the very high benchmark for range and nuance he had set in the role of LIng in the psychological thriller Mars.

The second time around, as I tried to follow the details of the extremely convoluted plot that forms the ‘canon’ for my fan fiction, I changed my mind. Zai Zai’s character was a very complex and volatile; he often put up a façade of joking and showing off while at his most serious. And Zai Zai had to convey these levels of meaning while also trying to render the gothic horror elements of the plot realistic and sympathetic.

In considering Zai Tian’s transformation from ugly homeless scavenger to handsome playboy at the hands of expert South Korean plastic surgeons, I was reminded of a line from an Ann Schlee novel, The Proprietor, in which the omniscient narrator says about a young woman castaway that she is so beautiful it is almost a disfigurement. Zai Zai conveys this sense of shock in that most Lovecraftian of all scenes when he regains consciousness in a swish waterfront apartment and catches a glimpse of his new visage in a mirror. He is of course horrified at this violation of his identity, but in fact he may also be confronted by having been made so alarmingly beautiful. This a tremendously affecting scene and on second viewing I would have given the acting prize to Zai Zai based on that one moment alone. (BTW, gents, if you ever want a little work done, Seoul is obviously the place to go.)

It’s a shame the sequel project has broken down because in fact I’m a fan of both the leads. And whether or not a viewer is inclined to acknowledge a homoerotic subtext in the series as some reviewers have, it was the relationship between Pizi and Ying Xiong more than any of the pairings in the plot’s web of hetero amours that was the most dynamic, had the most chemistry and was the only one that after all really mattered. Director Tsai Yueh Hsun has been quoted as saying there could be no future Pizi Ying Xiong without Pizi, and he is right. However much I admire Mark Zhao’s acting, I will not be seeking out the new, so-called sequel.

I had thought to scupper my fan fiction, too, but then V and another slashy blogger both pointed out to me that the demise of the sequel gives me more scope to play around with the characters and plot of my fan fiction. They reminded me that most great slash fan fiction has been written about series that are long over with: Star Trek, Man from UNCLE, Firefly, etc., etc. Moreover, the prompting from the Muse to write the further adventures of Pizi and Ying Xiong is still there, as urgent as ever. I might revisit the two or three drafts I’ve already written of the jacuzzi scene and see if I can get Ep 4 out there this week. Or next weekend. But, diis volentibus, soon.

*(Mark has emerged as one of the industry’s worse watering pots, perhaps even eclipsing the lachrymose James Zhu. Meanwhile, a talented young fan fiction writer informed me recently that the tear-from-one-eye thing is also popular in Western series, and is in fact the stock in trade of Jensen Ackles, who plays Dean Winchester in Supernatural).

Credits: Screen caps from Black & White box set: Deltacom.com and Prajna Works

Series production credits: here

Translation credit, UDN article: fufu@CpopAccess

Early rumours of project breakdown: MediaCorp TV, 26 November 2009

Additional source: May Seah, Today, 14 August, 2009

Advertisement

Responses

  1. Okay, finally caught up on your posts and read it.

    I always thought the one-eye tear thing was because of bad timing since the tear from the other eye didn’t come yet. LOL! Never knew it was for dramatic effects. But thanks for enlightening me and getting me out of the dark. (But I find that way of crying too dramatic though unless someone can cry with one eye only then I’m convinced. NOT saying it couldn’t happen but I haven’t seen it yet to relate to.)

    Your description of Vic’s scene makes me want to watch though B&W is still on the bottom of my list of ‘To-Watch’ since I’m always afraid of really hype shows that fail to deliver.

  2. Go and watch this series! Put it at the top of your list, LOL. It had really high production values and the story combined elements of a political thriller, a police procedural and the standard TW romantic melodrama. I have seen nothing else like it in the thirty-odd TW television series I’ve seen. Amazing!

  3. Come on now! I have to finish a bunch of others first and clear it out of the way, you want me to post my to-watch stuffs on my blog?

    I need to finish MML (which I have 2 more eps) and White Robe of Love first. And then maybe I’ll consider since I would probably have to put P.S. Man on hold if I decided to pick B&W up.

  4. I was nagging, wasn’t I?
    I’m working my way through MML, too, but without English subs. I bought the box set in Taiwan. I also got a free poster of all the leads and Cyndi in the middle of them all, ROFL. And I’ve just seen the first two eps of Autumn’s Concerto with subs. (I saw an ep in TW and was intrigued by it).
    Lots to catch up with, I admit it.

  5. I don’t like Vick’s acting at all in B&W, probably because Chinese is my native language. He can’t say anything clearly and his acting is really fake to me. I like Mark’s acting much better. His talent was demonstrated again the movie Monga. I especially dislike Vick’s behavior after the Golden Bell ceremony. His blog started a lot of rumors which was never supported by any evidence. I really dislike this type of people who are so jelous of other’s talent that they try to ruin other’s career rather than improving their own skills and expanding their own knowledge.

  6. Hi DCLee, welcome to Neveridol.
    I’m a crossover fan and I’ve only been learning Chinese for a few years, so bad pronunciation doesn’t tend to worry me. (For example, I like Leon Williams’s roles, and he is said to be much worse than Zai Zai, LOL).
    From what I understand, Vic (Zai Zai) grew up in a country area of Taiwan where they did not speak standard Mandarin and he has never entirely shed his dialect accent. I’ve heard that they often dub his voice when he acts in mainland productions. I thought his sloppy pronunciation (which I sometimes noticed) suited the role of a character who had been homeless and grew up on the streets of the Port City. We my friend V and I visited Kaohsiung in January (she is very fluent in Chinese), taxi drivers and other country people often did not speak or understand all that much Mandarin, so it kind of fits.
    On the issue to the disagreement between Mark and Zai Zai, I think the tabloids blew it all out of proportion, and I didn’t know what to believe. I’m just sorry they’re not going to make the sequel with both the leads. The backers must have really been dismayed.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.